Wanted to help yall out and start a masterpost for the recipes. Please feel free to add your own! Ive found some cool ones.

White Unicorn Horn = Quartz + White Rose

Blue Unicorn Horn = Apatite + Blue Rose

Pink Unicorn Horn = Pink Dye + Pink Rose

Red Unicorn Horn = Red English Saddle Pad + Red Rose

Yellow Unicorn Horn = Yellow English Saddle Pad + Yellow Rose

Blue Rose = Alfalfa + Blue Dye

Green Rose = Alfalfa + Green Dye

Orange Rose = Alfalfa + Orange Dye

Pink Rose = Alfalfa + Pink Dye

Purple Rose = Alfalfa + Purple Dye

Red Rose = Alfalfa + Red Dye

Yellow Rose = Alfalfa + Yellow Dye

Molasses = Clover + White Rose

Labradorite = Quartz + Alfalfa

Garnet = Quartz + Carrots

Apatite = Quartz + Oats

Sapphire = Quartz + Molasses

Quartz = Labradorite + Oats

Enchanted Lake English Pad = White English Saddle Pad + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake English Bridle = Black English Bridle + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake English Saddle = Black English Bridle + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake Western Bridle = Black Western Bridle + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake Western Saddle = Black Western Saddle + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake Western Saddle Pad + White Western Saddle Pad + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Festive Orange English Pad = Garnet + Wales Background

Festive Orange Western Pad = Labradorite/Ruby + Wales Background

Shamrock Green Pad = Wales Background + Emerald

Werewolf = Black Dye + Grey Wolf

Dark Forest Background = Midnight Dye + Grey Wolf

Cherry Petals = Clover + Whistle

Variation Pass Token = Whistle + Emerald

*** The Cauldron also works like the Dyeing page where you can dye tack items.

Feel free to add anything you find, and I will add it to this list 😊