Recipes from the Witches Cauldron

Pine [Basic || 13 posts] on 10/30/2022 8:44 am

Wanted to help yall out and start a masterpost for the recipes. Please feel free to add your own! Ive found some cool ones.


White Unicorn Horn = Quartz + White Rose

Blue Unicorn Horn = Apatite + Blue Rose

Pink Unicorn Horn = Pink Dye + Pink Rose

Red Unicorn Horn = Red English Saddle Pad + Red Rose

Yellow Unicorn Horn = Yellow English Saddle Pad + Yellow Rose

 

Blue Rose = Alfalfa + Blue Dye

Green Rose = Alfalfa + Green Dye

Orange Rose = Alfalfa + Orange Dye

Pink Rose = Alfalfa + Pink Dye

Purple Rose = Alfalfa + Purple Dye

Red Rose = Alfalfa + Red Dye

Yellow Rose = Alfalfa + Yellow Dye

 

Molasses = Clover + White Rose

Labradorite = Quartz + Alfalfa

Garnet = Quartz + Carrots

Apatite = Quartz + Oats

Sapphire = Quartz + Molasses

Quartz = Labradorite + Oats

 

Enchanted Lake English Pad = White English Saddle Pad + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake English Bridle = Black English Bridle + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake English Saddle = Black English Bridle + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake Western Bridle = Black Western Bridle + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake Western Saddle = Black Western Saddle + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

Enchanted Lake Western Saddle Pad + White Western Saddle Pad + Plain Spooky Purple Witch's Hat

 

Festive Orange English Pad = Garnet + Wales Background

Festive Orange Western Pad = Labradorite/Ruby + Wales Background

Shamrock Green Pad = Wales Background + Emerald

 

Werewolf = Black Dye + Grey Wolf

Dark Forest Background = Midnight Dye + Grey Wolf

Cherry Petals = Clover + Whistle

Variation Pass Token = Whistle + Emerald

 

 

*** The Cauldron also works like the Dyeing page where you can dye tack items.

Feel free to add anything you find, and I will add it to this list ๐Ÿ˜Š

 


Sleepy

Post Count: 18

10/31/2022 9:59 am

Winter Background + Blowing Snow = Reindeer Calf

Saddles + Blowing Snow = Snowflake Saddle

Bridles + Blowing Snow = Snowflake Bridle

Edited 1 times



Katona

Post Count: 57

10/31/2022 1:36 pm

German Sheppard Dog + Black Dye = Werewolf 
German Sheppard Dog + Grey Dye = Grey Wolf
Lasso + Orange Dye = Earthworm

Edited 1 times


Tobiano Dutch WBs | Colourful TBs | Fancy Welshies | OG Georgian Grandes

Mushroom, Pangare and Manchado Mustang Projects



Cydonia

Post Count: 31

10/31/2022 9:59 pm

Mistletoe= Green rose + Holiday red english saddle pad

Silverbell Acres



SweetChinMusic

Post Count: 132

11/01/2022 12:34 pm

German Shepherd = Imaginary Friend + German Harness
Earth Worn = Lasso + Orange Dye

 

Red Dye = Apple + Ruby



Appalachia Mt

Post Count: 2

10/31/2026 8:20 pm

Where do you get an imaginary friend?



Brambles

Post Count: 112

11/01/2026 7:35 am

You guys are amazing!!! Iโ€™ll add my recipes when I get home. Desperately need a croissant for breakfast ๐Ÿฅ ๐Ÿ˜



Brambles

Post Count: 112

11/01/2026 8:45 am

Caramel Candy + Onyx = Black Floating Hearts
Caramel Candy + Rose Quartz = Pink Floating Hearts
Caramel Candy + Garnet = Orange Slime Canopy
Caramel Candy + Apatite = Blue Wisteria Canopy

Caramel Candy + Labradorite = Blue Slime Canopy
Caramel Candy + Amethyst = Purple Slime Canopy
 

Chocolate Candy + Rose Quartz = Pink Wisteria Arch

Chocolate Candy + Citrine = Yellow Wisteria Arch

Chocolate Candy + Onyx = Purple Wisteria Arch
Chocolate Candy + Amethyst = Purple Wisteria Canopy

Chocolate Candy + Ruby = Pink Wisteria Arch
Chocolate Candy + Apatite = Blue Lupine

Spooky Sour Apple + Spooky Sour Apple = Halloween Treat Bucket
White Skeleton Paint + Rainbow Sparkling Magic = Rainbow Skeleton Paint
(Any white skeleton paint + dye = dyed skeleton paint)
Empty tonic bottle + any dye = a tonic
 



Brumby

Post Count: 47

11/01/2026 10:07 am

Caramel Candy + Caramel Candy = Chocolate Candy
Chocolate Candy + Chocolate Candy = Spooky Sour Apple



BlackOak

Post Count: 87

11/01/2026 1:27 pm

Note, these are my notes since it started, there may be duplicates already mentioned.

First line is outcome, second line is first item and third line is second item.

 

Alfalfa Apple TreatAppleAlfalfa
Alfalfa Clover TreatCloverAlfalfa
ApatiteQuartzOats
AppleEarthwormAlfalfa
Black DyeGrey DyePurple Dye
Black RoseAlfalfaBlack Dye
Blue LupineOatsLabradorite
Blue RoseAlfalfaBlue Dye
Blue SapphireQuartzMolasses
Blue TonicEmpty Tonic BottleBlue Dye
Blue TonicPurple TonicWhite Tonic
Blue Unicorn HornApatiteBlue Rose
Burnt Leaf DyeBlack DyeOrange Dye
Cat Jack-O-LanternCarrotsRuby
Cherry Blossoms BackgroundAppleDark Forest Background
Cherry PetalsCloverBlowing Snow
Cherry PetalsCloverWhistle
Dark Emerald DyeAppleWales Background
Dark Emerald DyeBlack DyeGreen Dye
Dark Forest BackgroundGrey WolfMidnight Dye
Deep Blue DyeBlack DyeBlue Dye
EarthwormFleasFleas
EarthwormLassoOrange Dye
EmeraldQuartzClover
Enchanted Lake English BridleBlack English BridlePlain Spooky Purple Witch Hat
Enchanted Lake English PadWhite English PadPlain Spooky Purple Witch Hat
Enchanted Lake English SaddleBlack English SaddlePlain Spooky Purple Witch Hat
Enchanted Lake Western BridleBlack Western BridlePlain Spooky Purple Witch Hat
Enchanted Lake Western BridleBrown Western BridlePlain Spooky Purple Witch Hat
Enchanted Lake Western PadWhite Western PadPlain Spooky Purple Witch Hat
Enchanted Lake Western SaddleBlack Western SaddlePlain Spooky Purple Witch Hat
Enchanted Lake Western SaddleBrown Western SaddlePlain Spooky Purple Witch Hat
English Snowflake BridleBlack English BridleBlowing Snow
English Snowflake BridleBrown English BridleBlowing Snow
English Snowflake PadWhite PadBlowing Snow
English Snowflake SaddleBlack English SaddleBlowing Snow
English Snowflake SaddleBrown English SaddleBlowing Snow
Face Re-Roll TokenWerewolfDark Forest Background
Festive Orange English PadGarnetWales Background
Festive Orange Western PadLabradoriteWales Background
Festive Orange Western PadRubyWales Background
Fire and Ice English PadAppleGarnet
Floating HeartsAppleFriesland Background
GarnetQuartzCarrots
German Shepherd DogImaginary FriendGerman Harness
Great Horned OwlTurkeyCarrots
Green RoseAlfalfaGreen Dye
Green TonicBlue TonicYellow Tonic
Green TonicEmpty Tonic BottleGreen Dye
Grey TonicEmpty Tonic BottleGrey Dye
Grey TonicOrange TonicGreen Tonic
Grey TonicOrange TonicPurple Tonic
Grey TonicPurple TonicGreen Tonic
Grey WolfGerman Shepard DogGrey Dye
Haunted Black FrameFriesland BackgroundBlack Dye
Haunted Brown FrameStable BackgroundGrey Dye
Haunted Green FrameWales BackgroundGreen Dye
Haunted Purple FrameFriesland BackgroundPurple Dye
Heart Jack-O-LanternCarrotsCitrine
LabradoriteQuartzAlfalfa
Midnight DyeAppleApatite
Midnight DyeBlack DyePurple Dye
MistletoeGreen RoseHoliday Red English Pad
MolassesCloverWhite Rose
Mustard DyeBlack DyeYellow Dye
Mustard DyeOatsYellow Dye
Mysterious CandlesSinister CandlesWhite Polos
Oat Apple TreatAppleOats
Oat Clover TreatCloverOats
Orange CarnationMolassesGarnet
Orange RoseAlfalfaOrange Dye
Orange TonicEmpty Tonic BottleOrange Dye
Orange TonicRed TonicYellow Tonic
Pastel Rainbow TonicEmpty Tonic BottlePastel Rainbow Unicorn Horn
Pink RoseAlfalfaPink Dye
Pink TonicEmpty Tonic BottlePink Dye
Pink TonicRed TonicWhite Tonic
Pink Unicorn HornPink DiePink Rose
Plain Bat Witch HatQuartzPlain Black Witch Hat
Plain Bat Witch HatQuartzPlain Brown Witch Hat
Plain Black Witch HatBlue RoseBlack Dye
Plain Galaxy Witch HatLabradoritePlain Black Witch Hat
Plain Galaxy Witch HatLabradoritePlain Brown Witch Hat
Plain Ghost Witch HatApatitePlain Black Witch Hat
Plain Ghost Witch HatApatitePlain Brown Witch Hat
Plain Ghost Witch HatBlue SapphirePlain Black Witch Hat
Plain Ghost Witch HatBlue SapphirePlain Brown Witch Hat
Plain Orange Witch HatGarnetPlain Black Witch Hat
Plain Orange Witch HatGarnetPlain Brown Witch Hat
Plain Red Witch HatRubyPlain Black Witch Hat
Plain Red Witch HatRubyPlain Brown Witch Hat
Purple LupineAlfalfaAmethyst
Purple RoseAlfalfaPurple Dye
Purple TonicEmpty Tonic BottlePurple Dye
Purple TonicRed TonicBlue Tonic
QuartzLabradoriteOats
Rainbow TonicEmpty Tonic BottleRainbow Unicorn Horn
Rainbow Unicorn HornRainbow English PadCherry Petals
Rainbow Western PadCloverRed Rose
Red DyeAppleRuby
Red RoseAlfalfaRed Dye
Red RoseFloating HeartsCherry Petals
Red TonicEmpty Tonic BottleRed Dye
Red TonicOrange TonicWhite Tonic
Reindeer CalfWinter BackgroundBlowing Snow
Reindeer CalfWinter BackgroundHoliday Green English Pad
Reindeer CalfWinter BackgroundHoliday Red English Pad
RubyQuartzApple
Shamrock Green English PadEmeraldWales Background
Sinister CandlesMysterious CandlesBlack Dye
Spicy Blue TonicBlue TonicBlue Sapphire
Spicy Green TonicGreen TonicEmerald
Spicy Grey TonicGrey TonicOnyx
Spicy Orange TonicOrange TonicGarnet
Spicy Pastel Rainbow TonicPastel Rainbow TonicApatite
Spicy Pink TonicPink TonicRose Quartz
Spicy Purple TonicPurple TonicAmethyst
Spicy Rainbow TonicRainbow TonicLabradorite
Spicy Red TonicRed TonicRuby
Spicy TonicRed TonicOnyx
Spicy White TonicWhite TonicQuartz
Spicy Yellow TonicYellow TonicCitrine
Spooky Tattered ClothEarthwormApple
TurkeyGreat Horned OwlMolasses
Variation Pass TokenEmeraldWhistle
WerewolfBlack DyeGrey Wolf
WerewolfGerman Shepard DogBlack Dye
Western Snowflake BridleBlack Western BridleBlowing Snow
Western Snowflake BridleBrown Western BridleBlowing Snow
Western Snowflake PadWhite Western PadBlowing Snow
Western Snowflake SaddleBlack Western SaddleBlowing Snow
Western Snowflake SaddleBrown Western SaddleBlowing Snow
White RoseAlfalfaWhite Blanket
White TonicEmpty Tonic BottleWhite English Pad
White TonicEmpty Tonic BottleWhite Western Pad
White Unicorn HornQuartzWhite Rose
Wine DyeBlack DyeRed Dye
Yellow RoseAlfalfaYellow Dye
Yellow TonicEmpty Tonic BottleYellow Dye
Yellow TonicGreen TonicWhite Tonic


Brambles

Post Count: 112

11/01/2026 1:51 pm

Any idea how to get blowing snow? I've never found any


You must login to reply to this topic. Login here. Don't have an account? Join us.