I am not certain if it makes a difference or not but I believe there was a post of someone selling these recolors of the same bases as while ago and they were pretty popular. 

However there are a lot of new and different players since then so its likely to garner some interest since the old one is inactive. 

Edit: yeah it was this one. It was suuppper popular at the time. So I feel it could go either way. Its the same thing ago so no interest. New players might be interested or even previous buyers want different horses now.