I could agree with this and even go as far as letting the community pick all the time. It's tons of fun looking at them but debating between Bed and I over what we like best sometimes takes a bit longer than it should. It would mean results just post a few days later.

I think it'd be fun to have both! It's always cool to see what y'all like best, but then we also can involve the community more and celebrate people's cool work on a bigger scale. 

I honestly disagree with having the community pick a winner, in other games where this feature exists it very quickly becomes a popularity contest rather than what is objectively the best.

There is rarely an objective best, and this is why I'm suggesting two winners — one chosen by staff and the other by the community.